The iPad Vs the iPhone

Just been having a discussion on the iPad. We have had a look at the advantages of using this new piece of technology within an educational setting. There are many advantages but there are also disadvantages to using this within a classroom.

Advantages

• the screen size is a lot larger than that of the iphone making it easier for children to view.
• the images within the iPad are very symbolic which will make it easier for younger children to use. This is potentially easier than using computers or laptops with them as they do not have to spend ages looking for the right application or programme.
• It is a good size to use at desks within the classroom as it should not completely take up all the desk space.
• There is access to wi-fi internet and 3G Internet.
• It comes with built in speakers and microphone meaning that these do not have to be externally attached.
• Word processing is available.
• Through the iBooks application children are able to view books and store them without the need for storage space within the classroom.
• The iPad is relatively thin so it is not too bulky to holding or storing.

Disadvantages

• At the moment the iPad is quite expensive and most schools would not be able to afford any or many.
• It is very similar to a laptop which prompts the question why bother?
• There is only 10 hours of battery life which means that it would need to be recharged everyday if it was being used in the classroom. This leads to the idea of where do you charge all the iPads at the same time as this would take up rather a lot of sockets within the classroom.
• There is no camera and if one was needed or wanted to be used, it would have to be connected externally.
• Its does not have flash and this means that vokis and other applications would not be able to be used.
• There is an additional expense for the keyboard attachment and if the children were using the word processing the iPad would need to be laid flat. This would strain the eyes and the neck and is not good for the health of the children that would be using it.

At the moment I am swayed more towards the iPhone as i really like how it is hand held and easy to store within a pocket or a bag. It is a lot more transportable and would be good for use outside the classroom e.g. on a school trip. The iPad has a few more good applications but i'm sure that these will become available for the iPhone in the future. I feel that when I am more familiar with the iPad and have maybe had a chance to explore its potential for myself, it may change my opinion. So far i am in favour of the iPhone.